The author deftly weaves the dalkon shield drama into the larger story of the life of a oneofakind man, crafting a sweeping and spirited truelife tale with not only her firsthand experiences as the judges law clerk but also with unrestricted access to the judges personal files. A pharmaceutical company looks the other way as its promising new birth control product, the dalkon shield intrauterine device iud, endangers the lives of more than 2 million women around the world. The intrauterine contraceptive device sciencedirect. The dalkon shield came on the market in the united states in 1971, and during the four years that it. In 1974 the department of health, education and welfare ordered over 3,000 federally funded familyplanning clinics to stop prescribing the dalkon shield. The dalkon shield saga editorial 8 journal of family planning and reproductive health care 2003. In 1971, dalkon shields went to the market, beginning in the united states and puerto. The story of the dalkon shield bankruptcy sobol, richard b. The concerns regarding iud use in a woman with a history of pid are that it may be a. It was associated with a significant incidence of pelvic inflammatory disease pid and infertility. History of longacting reversible contraception larc in. The story of the dalkon shield bankruptcy ebook full. Davis, the dalkon shields primary inventor, claimed that users of his device had a 1. I also would like to thank my research assistant, andrew gordon, class of 1994, for his valuable assistance.
A book discussion guide university of minnesota press. The story of the dalkon shield bankruptcy, richard b. Robins company, dalkon shield intrauterine contraceptive, intrauterine contraceptives complications, intrauterine. Pdf intrauterine devices iuds are the most effective, reversible and longest acting birth control method. This new book is a recounting of the dalkon shield, widely used as a contraceptive iud for millions of women in the early 1970s. Winner of the american bar associations 1992 silver gavel award in recognition of an outstanding contribution to public understanding of the american system of law and justice. The recent report of 209 cases of septic spontaneous abortion and 11 maternal deaths in the united states in women using the dalkon shield intrauterine device iud raised the question about a possible causal relationship between the iud and pelvic sepsis. In which the dalkon shield has a paralyzing effect home. History of longacting reversible contraception larc in the. Devices such as the dalkon shield, silicone breast implants, and rely tampons are all examples of products that should never have been released. The story of the dalkon shield bankruptcy 1st edition. Between 1970 and 1974, when the manufacturer withdrew the device because. Destroyed by his own invention hugh davis had it all. Removal of the shield was most frequent during the first 24 hours after insertion, usually because of pain.
University of california press and wherever books are sold. In this brutal indictment of the birth control industry, nicole j. As many as 200,000 american women have testified that they were injured by the device and. The dalkon shield in nulliparous women sciencedirect. Despite these benefits, iuds have minimal market penetration in.
Iuds low cost make them the most popular method worldwide. The dalkon shield is a white piece of plastic less than two centimeters in diameter. The maverick judge who brought corporate america to justice by roberta walburn praise for the book an intimate, compelling portrait of a courageous and exceptional man who believed in justice and. It speaks to the depth of the tragedy and to the determination of women to fight.
Although palmer wanted more children, she also wanted to wait a few years before having her next child, so she began searching for an effective and safe contraceptive. Robins company, from purchase of the device in 1970 through tort litigation and bankruptcy settlement in 1988. Searle copper7 iud 19741986 tampons and toxic shock 19751985 parlodel 19801994 accutane 19822009. The dalkon shield was a contraceptive intrauterine device iud developed by the dalkon corporation and marketed by the a. The disproportionate damage to women from dangerous drugs and medical devices may 20. The books at hand tell the gruesome story of the dalkon shield, from its dominance of the iud market in the early 1970s to its official recall in 1984 for the havoc it had caused.
This years series, truth and reconciliation, history and justice, deals with attempts to achieve truth and reconciliation in the. Roberta walburns recent biography of judge miles lord and story of her year as his law clerk is, in significant part, about discovery in lawsuits brought by women harmed by the dalkon shield, an iud marketed by the a. Guide to the dalkon shield claimants trust collection 1938. Nicole j grant in this brutal indictment of the birth control industry, nicole j.
This book outshines recent others see engelmayer, lj 10185 in exposing. It was associated with a significant incidence of pelvic inflammatory disease. History of longacting reversible contraception larc in the united states in june 2016, the jacobs institute of womens health published a white paper summarizing the scientific evidence related to larc methods. Once these themes were brought together, not only academically but also in practice, tort law thinking could never be the same again. The sad legacy of the dalkon shield the new york times.
Robins company acquired the dalkon shield from the dalkon corporation, founded by hugh j. Dalkon shieldarchive 1 jump to navigation jump to search. The dalkon shield was found to cause severe injury to a disproportionately large percentage of its users, which eventually led to numerous lawsuits, in which juries awarded millions of dollars in compensatory and punitive damages. The dalkon shield was an intrauterine contraceptive device iud that women used in the early 1970s and 1980s. They require no effort for compliance and avoid systemic synthetic hormones.
The case has become the largest tort case in history, with approximately 200,000 claimants worldwide and will not be wound up for years to come. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Its shape resembles a round bug or fish with one large eye and five legs on each side. The 71 clinical trials of the dalkon shield show that when this device is. Dec 06, 1987 the dalkon shield an intrauterine contraceptive device is gone from the market now, but not forgotten. At any cost traces the history of a contraceptive device which sub. H robins executives and pathfinder fund administrators among others conspired in the early 1970s to dump hundreds of thousands of dangerous, unsterilized contraceptive devices unmarketable in the united states into the developing world, according to a recent analysis of government and other documents. Quackery has produced some of the most bizarre products and claims as to their usefulness that have ever been unleashed on the american public. Women who wore the dalkon shield, which was on the market from 1970 to 1974, ran more than twice the risk of other iud wearers of developing pelvic. History of longacting reversible contraception larc in the united states in june 2016, the jacobs institute of womens health published a white paper summarizing the. In order to understand the issues raised by this appeal, it is necessary to also summarize the history of the dalkon shield. As one of the nations oldest law firms and the oldest continuing wall street law practice in the united states, our growth and development often paralleled the major economic, social, and political events that have shaped our nation and the. In 1983, minnesota judge miles lord described the dalkon shield iuds as instruments of death, of mutilation, of disease.
The failure rates for different models vary between 0. As an activist, ross has written on reproductive justice activism and the history of african american women. Cadwaladers longstanding tradition of providing our clients with unparalleled service and legal expertise began with the firms founding in 1792. Grant documents the history of the dalkon shield case and places the controversy within a larger historical and social context, examining the ways in which social conditions affect womens choices about contraception. The collection also documents the establishment and tenyear history of the dalkon shield. A book about discovery in federal court would not appear to be a pageturner. Dalkon shield made history over thirty years ago, but medical device recalls are not a thing of the past. Aug 06, 2001 the high rate of side effects from the pill and the later scandal involving the aggressive marketing and defense of the dalkon shield intrauterine device, despite the manufacturers knowledge of safety problems led many women to question why birth control had to be aimed at women instead of men. He was just a man with a wife and two kids and perhaps a very limited life. Although there are some accounts from women who suffered adverse health consequences with use of this iud, the book focuses more on the history of the device, from its. Past series have explored the history of school desegregation, 1960s political activism, the value of human life, and sports in history. Miles lord roberta walburn published by university of minnesota press walburn, roberta. I am very grateful to my colleagues maria marcus, michael martin and sol schreiber for their thoughtful comments on prior drafts of this essay.
In terms of fairness and efficiency, the dalkon shield claimants trust achieved, in the opinion of many, the most successful resolution of a mass tort case in the twentieth century. The trust collection traces the history of the dalkon shield, the intrauterine. Drawing upon an analysis of thirty years worth of articles in medical journals and popular magazines, family. Davis, the dalkon shield s primary inventor, claimed that users of his device had a 1. Understand something of the history of unsafe products and. Click to download book b003hvj25sread bending the law. In 296 nonindigent nulliparous women wearing the dalkon shield, the pregnancy and medical removal rates calculated at the end of 12 months were 5. Six women had reportedly died as a result of the shield by june 1974, when a. Or so we often believe about the history of birth control in america. Robins, and painful side effects, it was over 15 years before its damaging effects were formally made public. The dangers of the dalkon shield iud were well known before the dump began in 1972. The importance of writing the book, she said, is to give voice to the legacy of dalkon shield women everywhere. The dalkon shield contained multifilament threads which were believed to transmit bacteria into the.
A recent history replete with compromise and capitulation has pushed a once promising and effective political movement to the brink of irrelevance. The maverick judge who brought corporate america to justice. Ross is an african american academic, feminist, and activist who advocates for reproductive justice, especially among women of color. Although there are some accounts from women who suffered adverse health consequences with use of this iud, the book focuses more. The story of the dalkon shield bankruptcy richard b. The disproportionate damage to women from dangerous. Despite questionable research conducted by its manufacturer, a. Robins and 21 women who were suing the contraceptive manufacturer for compensation and punitive damages. The dalkon shield was at the center of a heated lawsuit between the corporation a. Sobol has produced a readable yet fully researched and detailed study of the operation of the bankruptcy. Grant documents the history of the dalkon shield case and places the controversy within a larger historical and social context. Was the dalkon shield a safe and effective intrauterine device. From histology of uteri post hysterectomy, they found that iud users had chronic noninfectious inflammation in the endometrium that was not present in non iud users 9. Copper iuds are a form of longacting reversible contraception and are one of the most effective forms of birth control available.
Robins company in the us, the dalkon shield was a contraceptive device placed directly into a womans uterus that was supposed to prevent the development of a fetus in the uterus. The dalkon shield was an intrauterine contraceptive device iud that. Intrauterine devices iuds are the most effective, reversible and longest acting birth control method. Guide to the dalkon shield claimants trust collection 19381970.
Only a few months after the dalkon shield went on the market in 1971, reports of adverse reactions began pouring. Many negative ideas about the iud were developed because of the dalkon shield. Dalkon shield victim shares battle in book the morning. Thanks in large part to the trusts diligence, caution, and wise investments, the most seriously injured claimants saw their awards doubled. Hugh davis, inventor of the dalkon shield, wrote the introduction to seamans book and promoted the dalkon shield as a safer alternative. The dalkon shield claimants trust collection, 19382000 bulk 19701998, traces the history of the dalkon shield, the intrauterine contraceptive device manufactured and sold by the a. The human cost of the dalkon shield purports to focus on the human costs of the dalkon shield intrauterine contraceptive device iud during and following the prolonged litigation process. Control and the dalkon shield lisa baker, 2001 sage journals. This is an accessible history of the case by a veteran civilrights lawyer. Both these books chronicle the events surrounding the adverse effects of the dalkon shield intrauterine device.
Throughout the history of medicine, thousands of drugs have been developed, but only one has been influential enough to earn the title of simply, the pill. Davis, inventor of the dalkon shield, wrote the introduction to seamans book and promoted the dalkon shield as a safer alternative. Dowie, the prolific awardwinning journalist who broke the stories on the dalkon shield and on the ford pinto, delivers an insightful, informative. Addendum to the papers of the dalkon shield claimants. Search the history of over 424 billion web pages on the internet. So states mark dowie in this provocative critique of the mainstream american environmental movement. Evidencebased effectiveness and safety studies have demonstrated iuds rival sterilization. The shield, which was introduced in 1970, was used by nearly 3 million women, thousands of whom suffered infections, complicated pregnancies, and other side effects. History of the dalkon shield in 1966, robert israel and hugh davis from johns hopkins university reported their study to explain the possi ble mechanism of action of iuds.
Introduced in may 1950, the oral contraceptive pill is a medical innovation that has dramatically transformed generations. Dalkon shield users soon reported severe pelvic infections and perforations. For rewire radio, im jenn stanley, and this is choiceless. The type of frame and amount of copper can affect the effectiveness of different copper iud models. It had moved on from hugh davis and the dalkon shield. The dalkon shield an intrauterine contraceptive device is gone from the market now, but not forgotten. The chicago distribution center is temporarily closed. Addendum to the papers of the dalkon shield claimants trust a. Intrauterine device iud case western reserve university. The enormous variety of coils or iuds intra uterine devices that have been devised over time is very surprising. This article analyzes how medical and scientific discourses surrounding the dalkon shield legitimized and authorized the punishment and control of womens. In which the dalkon shield has a paralyzing effect home this recording response.
1449 40 324 972 317 1466 1149 458 251 945 1288 445 775 199 163 1606 555 607 133 318 427 1563 371 1329 932 1023 36 506 1188 857 103 267 848 1206 234 1232 1262 1478 1361 913 697 806 1030 762 1284 1089 1268